Georgia (Sangiovese) On My Mind (Dispatch From The 2014 Critics Challenge)

Vinted on June 26, 2014 binned in crowd pleaser wines, kick-ass wines, on the road, wine review

No, you didn’t see one of these selections coming, okay?

Don’t even try it. No one, least of all me, would buy it for even a second.

This Summer, I once again had the pleasure of judging at the Critics Challenge in (stay classy) San Diego, my second stint as a judge there. A more well-executed U.S. wine competition you’re unlikely to encounter, and the judging panels boast some impressive collective credentials. Before I get into the two most memorable (for me) wines coming out of this year’s incarnation of the event (full results are here), I should give you a quick primer on how Critics Challenge works.

The judges are paid (well… duh), and for two days each is given a series of wine flights organized by category and tasted blind (residual sugar, grape variety, and category are known, in some cases vintage as well). The judges work in pairs, awarding (or denying) medals as they deem appropriate, and each wine is officially awarded the highest of the two medals determined by the pair of judges. The assumption, of course, is that as judges we all know what the hell we’re doing.

For 2014, I was fortunate enough to be paired of with writer and educator Deb Parker Wong, someone for whom the term “consummate professional” was invented, and a judge with a methodically brilliant tasting approach. I’ll stop here before this turns into a Deb valentine, but I feel compelled to add that Deb also possesses the rare and uncanny ability to double the elegance quotient of any room into which she walks (since I possess the equally rare and uncanny ability to halve a room’s elegance quotient, our judging table vicinity essentially remained elegance neutral)…

This year, Critics Challenge head honcho, journalist, and all-around-nice-guy Robert Whitley asked us to add scores (egads!) to each wine, in addition to awarding medals and writing a tasting note. The score was an aspect I left mostly to Deb, since I can only really zero-in on score ranges at best (she left a good bit of the tasting note writing to me, so things worked out nicely, though as you might expect my notes were gonzo-pseudo-poetic and… strange).

While my tasting notes will no doubt strike most people as odd, they arguable were not as odd as one of the results of a category that Deb and judged. I don’t mean strange in a negative way here, I mean it in a holy-crap-get-the-f*ck-out-of-here-totally-shutup-that’s-awesome way.

2010 Frogtown Cellars “Bravado” (Georgia, $21)

And to what wine did Deb Parker Wong and I unanimously award a Platinum medal in the coveted (okay, that’s pushing it) “BLENDED RED SUPER TUSCAN NEW WORLD” category? A Sangiovese-based blend made from grapes grown at high-ish elevations in the storied winemaking province of… Georgia. Yes, that Georgia, Georgia as in the U.S. State of Georgia, the Georgia-On-My-Mind Georgia. This is why we taste them blind, folks. The grapes are grown at the foot of the Appalachian Mountains, and as far as this recipe is concerned, the frog hops really, really well. This is Sangio that actually smells and tastes of Sangio: tart red fruits, earth, dried orange peel, the works. It has Sangiovese’s acidic zing, as well, and a plummy richness and well-integrated woody spiciness. I haven’t fully processed this one yet, and part of my wine brain is still in shock, but this is a producer on whom we ought to be keeping an eye, and one that will no doubt help put the U.S. deep south on the winemaking map.

See? Told ya it was strange.


2012 Dutton-Goldfield Dutton Ranch Rued Vineyard Chardonnay (Russian River Valley, $50)

Deb and I didn’t judge this particular wine in our tasting flights, but I’d be crazy not to feature it after having tasted it at dinner following day one of Critics Challenge.

American wine competition mainstay (and now officially Chief Storyteller for Wilfred Wong (no relation to Deb) went so far as to give this not-so-little Chardonnay number 100 points during the 2014 Critics Challenge. I’m not going to go quite that far, but I am going to call it an officially Kick-Ass bottle of California Chard. That Dutton-Goldfield has superb fruit with which to work is pretty much beyond debate, though it can be debated whether or not their results are always superb. Happily, this Chardonnay, from Green Valley in RRV, is that. It’s rich, creamy, generous, floral, heady, captivating, and yet for all of the apricot intensity and breadth, a part of it remains citric, focused and lean. “Stunning” would be an appropriate descriptor, and one for which I’d gladly shell out fifty clams to be able to say (drunkenly, no doubt) after consuming a bottle of CA vino. If it could speak, this Chardonnay would be saying (in Ron Burgundy voice): “Iiiiiiiii don’t know how to put this, buuuuut… I’m-kind-of-a-big-deal.”

p.s. – I’m also pleased to report that Steve Mirassou’s Steven Kent Winery and La Rochelle wines fared very, very well at Critics Challenge 2014, but as a frequent 1WD reader, you not only possess above-average intelligence and good looks, but you also already knew that those were brands that should be on your California wine radar, right?






  • Karyn

    Great! Now that you're convinced that states other than CA can produce quality wines, PLEASE start reviewing NC wines. We have over 130 wineries in the state. Please make a trip out here and see that we are not producing just sweet muscadine wines. Many of us are producing dry, European-style wines.

    • 1WineDude

      Karyn – Thanks, but you've not been paying attention here. I have written about wine made in PA, OR, CO, VA, WA, AZ, NJ, NY, Idaho, MI… As I respond to you, I am in the middle of writing a 2K word article for an Italian wine magazine that covers wine made across the entire U.S.

      The abundant CA coverage here only represents the statistical fact that the state makes over 90% of all the wine produced in the U.S. and itself would be the world's 4th largest producer.

      I'm happy to check out the NC wine scene as soon as they invite me to do so. I don't mean to come down hard on you, but painting me (of all people) to be focused solely on CA is a substantial misrepresentation of the years of wine coverage here on 1WD.

  • Lenny Pepperidge

    What is that? A skyline for ants?

    • 1WineDude

      Lenny – I am pretty short…

The Fine Print

This site is licensed under Creative Commons. Content may be used for non-commercial use only; no modifications allowed; attribution required in the form of a statement "originally published by 1WineDude" with a link back to the original posting.

Play nice! Code of Ethics and Privacy.

Contact: joe (at) 1winedude (dot) com





Sign up, lushes!

Enter your email address to subscribe and get all the good stuff via email.

Join 36,922 other subscribers