Pinooooooooooh Yeeeeaaaah (Two Exceptional Pinot Noir Recent Releases)

Vinted on April 7, 2016 binned in kick-ass wines, wine review

Sometimes, the wine sample pool giveth, sometimes the wine sample pool taketh away (usually it taketh away my hope), and sometimes – very rarely – the wine sample pool giveth and then giveth some more.

Today’s focus is the latter; two Pinot Noir recent releases that are downright exceptional. Exceptional enough that I drank the shiz out of tasted them over several days. You know, just to be sure.

The first comes from a producer with which I’m peripherally familiar, having sampled some of their wares over the years, and been suitably impressed enough with their Sonoma releases to have featured one of them in the 2012 Most Interesting Wines of the Year round-up. I have even forgiven that producer – Donum Estate – for their borderline-garish tagline (“the gift of the land…” man, it’s even painful to type that).

The second is the inaugural release from Louis Jadot Estates‘ recently-acquired Résonance Vineyard; and it’s an effort that hits it so far out of the park at its first at-bat that it probably has well-established Yamill-Carlton producers ripping their hair out…


Donum 2012 Anderson Valley Pinot Noir


2012 Donum Estate grown Anderson Valley Pinot Noir (Anderson Valley, 1WD_Badge_KickAss_thumb1_thumb.jpg$72)

Interestingly, this might not technially be the best sample of Donum’s wines that was sent to me (that nod probably should go to their 2012 Carneros Pinot bottling, not that their 2013 Carneros Chardonnay is anything to sneeze at, mind you). However, the 2012 Anderson Valley just sums up so powerfully what’s intriguing about great AV Pinot that I kept coming back to this wine over and over again after several days. Donum have a cool Anderson Valley spot at their Angel Camp vineyard, with a good amount of fog influence. They’ve also got seven different Pinot clones (six of which find their way into this release), five different French oak barrel types, and what seems a borderline-obsession when it comes to blending the final wine, which clocked in at a mere 348 cases.

There are a lot of opposing forces at work in this Pinot. Deep blackberry and dark cherry fruits facing off against tart cranberry; baking spices shouldering up to violets; bright acidic lift arm-wrestling the intense fruitiness and alcoholic power. The result of all of that tension are senses of balance and intensity that justify the high price tag.


Resonance 2013 Pinot Noir

1WD_Badge_KickAss_thumb1_thumb.jpg2013 Louis Jadot Estates Résonance Vineyard Pinot Noir (Yamhill-Carlton, $65)

This, my peeps, is one crazy-ass wine.

Résonance was first planted in 1981, on un-grafted (and un-irrigated) vines. While Jadot has been doing the Pinot thang in Burgundy since the mid-1800s, this is their first project outside of the safety of their French roots. That they got it so right so quickly is a testament, I think, to how damned good they are at picking Pinot locales (this one having been acquired in August, 2013). Winemaker Jacques Lardière’s having forty-plus vintages under his belt didn’t hurt, either.

The wine opens with tart red fruits, peppery spices, hints of earth, and wild raspberries. There’s lots of structure for a Pinot, and lovely, focused acidity. So, the thing is definitely drinkable (like, really drinkable) now. BUT… the arc of this thing after being opened suggests an interesting life ahead. After two days open, this wine goes nuts. It gets earthy, plummy, and powerful, to the extent that it could almost fool you into thinking that you were drinking Cabernet (despite the light 13.1% abv). Give it a day or two more, and it’s back to the red berry fruitiness of traditional Pinot, with more pleasant earthiness and wet leaf action. A chameleon of sorts, but one whose every color change is a small, artistic spectacle in and of itself.






  • Paul Moe

    Do you publish approximate retail prices? If so, what’s the tariff here? Is there any chance of finding these wines in south Florida?

    • 1WineDude

      Hi Paul,

      The prices that I publish are all approximate retail prices. In terms of whether or not the wines are available to/near you, your best bet is to click on the linked wine name (or the “Find this wine” link for mini-reviews), which will take you to the wine-searcher website, where you can see what purchase options are available). Cheers!

  • Sahmmilier

    Sorry you’ve had such a rough week ;). Love the idea of chameleon wine. Maybe one day…

    • 1WineDude

      Sahmmilier – as I like to tell people right now, I think that lately I’ve earned it! ;-)

  • Lars

    I’m so glad I came across your post. I’ve had many a wines from the Resonance vineyard prior to the Jadot acquisition (mostly from Big Table Farm) and have wondered how the new vintage would be. As a fan of the 2013 Oregon Pinots in general, it’s no surprise how awesome this one sounds. Going to pick up several bottles of this while I can. Thanks!

    • 1WineDude

      Thanks, Lars. One word of caution: while I’m confident it’s an awesome Pinot, I’ve no prior experience with the vineyard. So I can’t say whether or not it’s indicative of previous/other releases crafted from that vineyard.

  • Mahee Ferlini

    I am so happy I came across this post, I love Pinot Noir!

    • 1WineDude

      :) Thanks, Mahee!

The Fine Print

This site is licensed under Creative Commons. Content may be used for non-commercial use only; no modifications allowed; attribution required in the form of a statement "originally published by 1WineDude" with a link back to the original posting.

Play nice! Code of Ethics and Privacy.

Contact: joe (at) 1winedude (dot) com





Sign up, lushes!

Enter your email address to subscribe and get all the good stuff via email.

Join 36,929 other subscribers