The Greatest California Vineyard You Don’t Know About (Communing – And Drinking! – With Old Souls In Lodi)

Vinted on March 27, 2012 binned in elegant wines, on the road, overachiever wines, wine review

Well, you may actually know about it, but that would certainly put you in better shape than I was when my friend and sommelier legend Randy Caparoso kidnapped me from Premiere Napa Valley in February, insisting that I spend some time in Lodi to see some down-home, old school wine farming.

What I wasn’t entirely prepared for was just how old that old school was going to be.

As in, going on 126 years old, old. Think about that the next time you read the words “old vines” printed on a wine label; you know, right before you think “well, hell, I know some really old vines, suckah!.

What Randy insisted on showing me first was Lodi’s Bechthold Vineyard, nestled in the Mokelumne River area and home of Cinsault vines planted in 1886 on their own roots (on which they remain, thanks to sandy soils and a deep root system preventing the vine-killer phylloxera from picking them off) by German immigrant Joseph Spenker; the place has been continuously dry-farmed – and family-owned – ever since.

And the place is nothing short of magical, if you’re a real wine geek. Because older souls you are not likely to encounter in California, unless your house is haunted or you live among the redwoods. And when you’re done reading this, you hopefully won’t wonder why I went ga-ga over the Single Vineyard concept for WBW75 (and be thirsting for some Cinsault, or Lodi wine, at least)…

Being in the presence of vines that predate automobiles, both World Wars, and the eight-hour workday (seriously… look it up!…) and that are still producing fruit… that’s a tough one to put into words. Communing with those gnarly, old souls – and that’s really what you’re doing if you visit as a wine geek – isn’t something you talk about so much as experience, which is probably why Randy didn’t say much about it and just insisted that we stop there first during our visit.

And I know what you might be thinking… well, you write, don’t you? so at least give it a try, man! 

But the truth is that I have tried, five or six times, and every version fell short of the reality of being there, because it isn’t something that gets transmitted through the smell of the green cover crop, or the warmth of the air, or even the sight of the vines… it’s all of those things, and… something else, something more. Something that doesn’t make sense until you’re in the presence of living things that can easily outlast your time here on mama Earth, to which you’re literally little more than a transient specter.

The Bechthold vines are borderline-ancient, but in such amazing shape that their twisted tendrils make them look as if they’re dancing, celebrating for the sheer joy of still being alive. And the fruit still being produced by them is superb, if the finished wines into which they’re made are any indication.

That the Bechthold vineyard survived the early 2000s, when the Bechthold family were getting a measly $200 a ton for its grapes (you can blame the location, and the fact that the grapes were labeled as “Malvoisie” – basically a price-killing combination in the CA wine biz), is a bit of a minor miracle. Wanda Woock Bechthold, now in her early eighties, had UC Davis check out the grapes, which were identified as Cinsault (took them long enough, didn’t it?) and were then pitched to higher-end clients (a list that now includes Bonny Doon, Turley Wine Cellars, Phoenix Vineyards and Michael-David), effectively raising the prices, justifying the farming costs, and saving the magic.

Randy has authored a recap of the vineyard’s history, and an interview with the Bechtholds and their clients, on the Lodi Wine blog. I’ll sum it up using this quote from Randy’s story, which to me kind of says it all:

Randall [Grahm, of Bonny Doon], came out with a friend from France, Nicolas Joly (France’s best known biodynamic proponent).  Nicolas was amazed by the inherent vigor and health of the vines, and the quality of the grapes – declaring it ‘the equal to any Cinsault plantings he had ever seen in France.’”

If you want to go off the deep end on the place’s history, you can check out Mrs. Bechthold’s book on the subject. What Randy and I opted for was to sample some wines created from the vineyard’s grapes, which we did while standing in the vineyard itself… can’t get much more connected and down-home than that, I suppose (how Bohemian of us, right?). The biggest take-away for me? Don’t let anyone ever tell you that Cinsault cannot make world-class wine on its own. Take the ratings with a grain of salt, as always – trying to pin wines like these down to a snapshot/score for me is like letting a tiny piece of your soul die…


2010 Phoenix Ranch Bechthold Vineyard Cinsault (Lodi)
Price: $21
Rating: B+

I am going to tell you now that this wine catapulted itself into the running for the 1WD Most Interesting Wines Of The Year list on first whiff. This wine is like crack cocaine for Cinsault lovers (admittedly, all twelve of us…) – peppery, with understated, elegant red berry and dark cherry fruits… it’s deep, focused (as you’d expect from older vines producing intense, small berries), with plum fruits coming out towards the end of the sip and there’s a wonderful structure underneath it all that is both focused and vibrantly joyous at the same time (if that makes any sense). This is old souls showing how it’s done.


2010 Miner’s Leap Cinsault (Lodi)
Price: $28
Rating: B+

Miner’s Leap has gone full-on pretty with this wine, focusing on the purity of the red berry fruit. It has depth as well, but femininity reigns supreme with this juice, and if you’re looking for the softer, contemplative side of Cinsault then this is your puppy right here.

An honorable mention goes to the third wine that we tried in the vineyard on that sunny late February day, the 2006 Jessie’s Grove “Sin So” Cinsault (Lodi, about $35). It doesn’t get a badge because I don’t have a badge for “Ballser.” To make a long story short, winemaker Greg Burns (who is Wanda Woock Bechthold’s son) decided that, since Cinsault is one of the most anti-oxidative grapes, they would see how it held up against an oxidative treatment in the winery (the aging required accounts for why the 2006 is the current release). It’s a wine of dry fruits and flowers and caramelized notes, and is best described as an awesomely geeky experiment – one to try for the Cinsault-ultra-curious, but probably not one to pop open for your friends.

Now, if you’re wondering how big some of the old, Old Vines can get, I’ll leave you with this photo, taken by Randy, of little-ol’-130-some-odd pound-and-5’5”-ish me “dwarfed” by an ancient Tokay vine in Lodi… just go easy on the height jokes, okay?…






  • 1WineDude

    This just in from a reader via e-mail…

    "I will overlook the chance to make height jokes. I look down on people who do so and give them short shrift in conversation. Such behavior is beneath me."


  • talkavino


    you are right – I never heard of this vineyard and never saw the old vines like this – definitely sounds like a place I would love to visit!


    • 1WineDude

      talkavino – not much there in that vineyard… except for those old souls! :)

  • @dvinewinetime

    I really appreciate you taking the time to talk about the "old school" farming of Lodi and sharing it w/ the world with a feeling of open mindedness. Seeing it the way it used to be and not only amazed by it; but appreciating it. Lodi's where I currently call home & although I've only been here a few years, I fell in love w/ what was ancient & simple here in this "wine country of old". Ive witnessed 1st hand what you describe; It's hard to relay it's profoundness to others that have not stood in a vineyard & seen such old, Gnarly, elegant vines. You captured it extremely well in this post. Thanks for reminding the wine folks how important Lodi, CA is to the wine community! Great Post! Cheers!

    • 1WineDude

      @dvinewinetime – Thanks. You want Old School, wait until you see what I post on Thursday… :)

  • Ed Thralls Jr

    Very cool. At Rhone Rangers this weekend Michael David had a 100% Cinsault (which was awesome) that they said was from 135 year old vines, but I don't exactly where they are. Also, Kunde Family Estate has 132 year old Zinfandel Vines in Sonoma Valley. As you probably also know, Calistoga is home to some century old vines of various varieties planted by the early Italian settlers… many varieties that can't be determined too. Can't wait for the video.

    • Jon Bjork

      Ed, Michael-David makes their 100% Cinsault from the Bechthold 1886 Vineyard. Kevin Phillips – the son of the "Michael" in Michael-David – farms the Bechthold vines for all those mentioned in Joe's blog. (Someone was just off in their math.) And as you mentioned, I've been a fan of Zin from Sonoma's Pagani Ranch, which I believe is one of the oldest in your neck of the woods.

    • 1WineDude

      Thanks, Ed – not sure when it's posting at but imagine it would be in the next few weeks. Cheers!

    • 1WineDude

      Well, this is timely – video is published over at, so you can check it out now :).


  • winito

    Michael Davids Cinsault comes from this same vineyard.

  • Jon Bjork

    Thanks again for visiting our home town of Lodi, Joe! Really appreciate all the attention you've focused on this very inspiring vineyard.

    • 1WineDude

      Thanks for having me, Jon :).

  • Fred Swan

    Hey Joe, kudos to you for the excellent post and your high level of journalistic integrity. You could have totally said you were standing next to a massive oak tree and people would've thought you amazingly tall.

    • 1WineDude

      Fred – ha!!! Hadn't thought of that… clever…

  • Jerry

    Great post Joe. Makes me want to try some Cinsault from Lodi. On a completetly shameless note, I wonder if they sell their grapes to home winemakers. Most likely not, but I have to ask.

    • 1WineDude

      :) Thanks, Jerry!

  • Mary

    just started drinking a bunch of old vine Zin from Lodi. Enjoying it greatly!!

    • 1WineDude

      Thanks, Mary – enjoy it. Just be careful of the lofty ABVs on some of those… :)

  • gdfo

    Now there is a story!

    • 1WineDude

      Thanks, gdfo!

  • Vinogirl

    I love the Phoenix Ranch Cinsault. Have been meaning to buy a six-pack of it now for a few months, but keep forgetting. I'll see the proprietor this Saturday evening , so…

    • 1WineDude

      Thanks, Vinogirl – money well-spent there!

  • Lisa Khajavi

    Love these gnarley, beautiful old vines! They are full of time-earned character, so cool! Veritable sculptures, and if they could talk….

    • 1WineDude

      Lisa – soooo true, such a great way of describing them!

  • Wineguys TV

    The Old Vine Term comes from and started from where?

    • 1WineDude

      Wineguys – Dunno; my understanding of the genesis of the term in the U.S., just in terms of who first started using it on labels, is Dry Creek Vineyard in Sonoma.

The Fine Print

This site is licensed under Creative Commons. Content may be used for non-commercial use only; no modifications allowed; attribution required in the form of a statement "originally published by 1WineDude" with a link back to the original posting.

Play nice! Code of Ethics and Privacy.

Contact: joe (at) 1winedude (dot) com





Sign up, lushes!

Enter your email address to subscribe and get all the good stuff via email.

Join 36,893 other subscribers