Sex? Or Death? Oh, And Rare Monbazillac (Chateau Bonnet Recent Releases)

Vinted on November 21, 2012 binned in crowd pleaser wines, elegant wines, on the road, overachiever wines, wine review

In high school, I had a math teacher who used to tease us when we were timid in class about providing an answer that should have been obvious. He would hold out his lanky arms in the fashion of scales, feigning the weighing of agonizing choices, while muttering, “Sex? Or… death? Sex… or death? I can’t decide!!”

So when I was in Bordeaux this past September (a media guest of Planet Bordeaux), and oenologist Vincent Cruège asked my group if we wanted to meet André Lurton, I had a flashback to those high school days. Now near 90, Lurton – apart from being a near-legend in Bordeaux winemaking – has been Mayor of Grézillac, a WWII soldier, a Military Cross recipient, member of the Legion of Honour, a Knight of the Agricultural Order of Merit, and a collector of… tanks (not steel tanks, though there are plenty of those on the property, but the kind of tanks that shoot explosive shell rounds).

“Sex? Or Death?”

Hell yeah, I wanted to meet Lurton. I’d want to meet him by virtue of the tank collection alone, actually.

And so it was that our tour of Chateau Bonnet, headed by Lurton’s daughter Denise Moulle (whose husband, Jean-Pierre, was head chef at Chez Panisse for more than twenty years, but as far as I’m aware didn’t cook for us during this visit… the audacity…!) was to conclude with a visit from the tank-collecting legend himself, who basically heard that we were a group of bloggers and wanted to meet the new blood in the wine biz. It would also conclude with the popping of the cork on one of Lurton’s rarer Monbazillacs – something I didn’t know when we toured the grounds on a chilly, wet Autumn mid-morning, but something else I certainly wouldn’t have turned down if it had been offered (talk about “Sex or Death?”)…

Lurton’s ancestors purchased Chateau Bonnet in the 1880s, on the cheap due to the phylloxera outbreak having decimated the vineyards. It’s been a slow but successful climb up from there, with the Lurtons now commanding some large vineyard holdings and big production numbers (nearly a million bottles of exported wine, and that’s not counting the whites) in inexpensive Bordeaux (more on those wines in a bit). But the changing tide of the American market, wine media and tastemakers, who seem to find it de rigueur to diss Bordeaux winemaking as largely overpriced and greedy (I’m certainly guilty to some extent) has definitely ruffled the Lurton family feathers.

“When I started in the States in the 1980s, Bordeaux was the reference,” Denise told me as we toured the property (and as I tried not to dance around while trying to stay warm in the spitting rain). “Now, in people’s minds in the U.S., it’s expensive wine. But most are not even twenty dollars, they are easy wines! At very good prices! But they are brainwashed by Wines of the Languedoc, Wines of Chile. These guys that live on eighty acres here, they are barely able to survive! They will get bought up by the Chinese. But they are the blood of this country, the yeast in its bread.”

I don’t think the lady doth protest too much, either. Missing the budget side of Bordeaux is missing almost the entire point of Bordeaux wine, the vast majority of which is made for early consumption on dinner tables worldwide while being easy on the wallet. And if the celebrated Merry Edwards cut her winemaking teeth on Sauvignon Blanc here, that should tell you that there’s more to the Lurtons than bulk production.

There have been some changes at Lurton in response to the market, which likely helps account for some of their continued success. Most recently, seeing a jump in rosé sales spurred a retooling of their rosé production and picking techniques to help improve overall quality. Despite the haphazard appearance of a hodgepodge of equipment from multiple decades (partly a function of sharing that equipment between Lurton properties), I got the sense that Chateau Bonnet is nothing if not well-run.

And Lurton’s passion for machinery clearly extends beyond military vehicles; among the sheds at the Chateau, one can find enormous modern harvesting machines, spherical tanks for lees storage (nicknamed “Sputniks” for reasons that will be obvious when viewing the inset pic), and large rotating tubes that cut grape solids from tanks juice, creating sheets that are reused as vineyards fertilizer.

Anyway… onto the results of all of that work, the wines themselves, and the meeting with The Master, which took place in an imaginative grotto on the property that had been built with stone, concrete and hand-wrought iron by Andre’s father…

As for the man himself, there’s nothing boastful or assuming about his character. He’s still relatively sharp and quick-witted, though he doesn’t get around all that easily. To me, he seemed as though he could pass for the father of the Most Interesting Man In The World from the beer commercials – at once approachable, well-composed, and, well, interesting.

I’d love to recount Lurton’s tales of the founder of the Chateau, who hid in a well on the property during the French Revolution, taking food passed to him through a small window; but you had to be there, really.

As I’m fond of doing for folks who have been around the wine block, I asked him what the biggest change has been since he started his wine career. “All the time, I’ve changed everything,” he told me, meaning that he has constantly been tinkering with the larger Lurton machinery, if you will. But when I pressed him for the biggest change, he thought for a moment and answered “the arrival of the harvesting machine in 1972; after that, we changed everything to match the machine.” Ah, another sea change rendered by technology (and, eerily, yet another 40th anniversary mention I’ve encountered in the world of wine this year).

All the while the gentleman, too; Lurton was concerned after our tasting that we were being served coffee, noting that it might interfere with our palates if we were tasting on our next visit. At which point, daughter Denise betrayed a bit of precociousness (I knew I liked her for some reason!), admonishing her dad and jokingly quipping, “they’re going to another producer, so we don’t care!”

For the record, we did drink the coffee…


2011 Chateau Bonnet Blanc (Entre-deux-Mers)
Price: $9
Rating: B

Kind of defies logic, really, in the quality you’re getting for the price. A Sauvignon Blanc, Semillon and Muscadelle blend, you’re basically traipsing through white flowered fields with this. There’s also a good deal of pithy citrus, chalk, cream, perfume… Balanced minerality and richness… F*ck, it’s just delightful, okay?


2011 Chateau Tour de Bonnet Rosé (Bordeaux)
Price: $6
Rating: B-

This line(Tour de Bonnet, I mean) is apparently a Total Wine exclusive, which for me means I might have to take a trip to TW (in DE of course… whoops, am I supposed to type that as a PA resident?) the next time I need to load up on wine for Springtime outdoor activities. Roses, pepper, citrus pith, bright cherries; they’ve coaxed a lot of tastiness out of those Merlot and Cabernet Sauvignon grapes.


2009 Chateau Bonnet Rouge (Bordeaux)
Price: $12
Rating: B-

Merlot and Cab, this time full-on. Herbal and plummy, hints of leather and backing spices. It’s Old World, despite a touch of vanilla creeping around the back and looking disreputable, but overall the whole thing is fresh, vibrant and light, and (most importantly) easy to like. In the immortal words of Marvel Comics, “‘Nuff said!”


2008 Chateau de Grossombre de Saint-Joseph (Bordeaux)
Price: $19
Rating: B

This line is headed up by Denise’s sister Beatrice (who we didn’t meet). On the whole, it’s a slightly more sophisticated dressing than the Bonnet’s are wearing, which we can chalk up to the graphite and cigar box spiciness. It’s softer and richer than the Bonnet reds, too, but the red fruits are still bright. It also gets a slight edge on the Bonnet in how long the finish lasts; all in all, Beatrice served up a wine that’s just a tad more generous as a host (but a good deal pricier as a result… though we’re still talking under twenty bones here, people).


1990 Domaine Bernas-Malfourat (Monbazillac)
Price: N/A
Rating: Beeeatch, puh-leeeze!

Okay, kept you in suspense long enough… 1990 was the first vintage of Bernas-Malfourat ever made (and there wasn’t a whole lot more made after that). Cruège – a fairly soft-spoken guy – looked borderline-amazed when this bottle got popped, stating that it was “the first time I’ve had this in twenty years.” He went to explain the odd history of the wine. Back in `90, he received a call from Lurton, who told Cruège that “the following Monday I’d need to be in Monbazillac for harvest. I said ‘what Montbazillac harvest?!?’” Lurton had driven by the property, fell in love with what he saw, and basically had purchased the grapes on the spot. This wine is a botrytized white, and carries the yeasty, toasty, deeply concentrated dark honey funk that is part-and-parcel of the Noble Rot.

My tasting notes include the phrase “f*ck, this is glorious.” Which could have been just for the amazing dark gold color alone. Let’s get the litany of descriptors out of the way now: crème brûlée, caramel, toasted nuts, apricots, brandy, dried white figs, toffee, and a sh*tload of sultanas. The finish is sweet, spicy, toasty and somehow… assertive. Like being force-fed an incredible biscotti (maybe that will make sense if you ever get to try it… the wine, I mean, not being force-fed a biscotti). Texturally, there’s plenty of verve and freshness to support the sweetness, so while it is certainly luscious, it’s only really got a touch of viscosity.






  • fredric koeppel

    ok, great, but did you get to ride in a tank?

    • 1WineDude

      Fredric – uhmmm… errrr…. No. :-(

  • Massase Bergen

    Amazing post dude !!! I just wanted to observation your blog and say that I actually enjoyed reading your blog post here about sex or death. It was very terrific and instructive. Keep it up and I’ll be back to read more soon.

    • 1WineDude


The Fine Print

This site is licensed under Creative Commons. Content may be used for non-commercial use only; no modifications allowed; attribution required in the form of a statement "originally published by 1WineDude" with a link back to the original posting.

Play nice! Code of Ethics and Privacy.

Contact: joe (at) 1winedude (dot) com





Sign up, lushes!

Enter your email address to subscribe and get all the good stuff via email.

Join 37,163 other subscribers