1 Wine Dude

A Serious Wine Blog For the Not-So-Serious Drinker

Menu
  • Home
  • About
    • New? Start Here!
    • PR & Samples
    • Press & What-Have-You
  • Wine
    • by badge
      • crowd pleaser
      • elegant
      • kick-ass
      • overachiever
      • sexy
    • Full Reviews
    • Mini-Reviews
  • Stalk
    • Follow me on News Break!
    • facebook
    • Instagram
    • LinkedIn
    • pinterest
    • twitter
    • YouTube
  • Sign Up
  • Books
  • Services
  • Contact
Menu
1 Wine Dude

Don’t Feed the Trolls: How NOT to Respond to Public Criticism3 min read

Posted on August 23, 2008 by 1WineDude

in commentary

By now, many of you will already have heard about the controversy surrounding Wine Spectator’s restaurant awards that unfolded into the mainstream media this week.

This topic is getting about as visible a media treatment as the wine world ever gets, so I won’t rehash the complete story here. To get us all up to speed and on the same page, the sequence of events goes something like this (in the immortal words of Inigo Montoya, “Let me explain. No – is not time; lemme sum up!”):

  • Robin Goldstein, author of The Wine Trials, claims that Wine Spectator awarded his fake Italian restaurant with an Award of Excellence for their wine list, which included several “reserve” wines that were previously panned by WS reviewers.
  • The press jumps on the news, and the Internet becomes awash in overly negative criticism of WS.
  • It’s learned that Goldstein withheld important facts about the extent of his complex ruse to fake out WS (such as creating a website, restaurant reviews, and phone number for his fake restaurant, as well as omitting to the press that his wine list’s crap reserve wines comprised about 5% of the total wine list submitted to WS).
  • WS responds to the Goldstein’s claims, but oddly does so in their on-line forum at WineSpectator.com, and not through a PR effort.
  • Chaos ensues.

Regardless of which side of this issue you stand, if you’re like me you’re probably scratching your head as to why WS chose an on-line forum post as the, well, forum to use for publishing their defense of the Restaurant Awards process. Especially considering that this event is all over the news right now.

The problem with this approach is that the WS forum is full of “trolls,” and has become a hotbed of negativity.

I can vouch for this personally…


In my attempts to open a discource with the editors of WS (to better understand why their initial response did not include any details regarding if/how the Awards process would be examined to ensure it maintains credibility), I had to go to the WS forums. After all, that’s where the WS editors posted their response in the first place.

I (and other wine bloggers) have been greeted there with a negativity unbecoming of a long-running institution such as WS. While the editors, for the most part, have been civil in their responses, some of the forum members have been downright nasty. I’ve had to endure blogging being dismissed as “lazy journalism,” and having my SWE and CSW credentials called fakes. Little (if any) moderation seems to be taking place in the forum at the moment, and new forum members are told to “STFU” and “go away.” Even senior WS editor James Suckling seemed to get into negative mode when addressing particularly vehement criticism on the forum.

Of course, not all of the forum members are acting in a negative way, but enough are being malicious to prevent an appropriate discourse with the WS editors. When I asked the forum members why new posters were greeted with that level of negativity, I was told it’s the equivalent of “initiation.”

Hazing is more like it.

Here’s my simple plea to the editors of WS:

If you’re going to allow your on-line forums to be the equivalent of a shark tank, then please put your response to Goldstein’s criticism into the hands of a PR director, where it belongs. Otherwise, those of us looking for constructive, open discourse on the topic of WS’ restaurant awards have nowhere to turn.

As long as your on-line forum remains the primary vehicle for your response to the Goldstein event, you will be promoting the impression that you are not taking the matter seriously.

It’s not events like this that make or break your credibility; it’s your response to events like this that make it or break it.

Cheers!

(image: salagir.com)


  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • More
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)

Related

9 thoughts on “Don’t Feed the Trolls: How NOT to Respond to Public Criticism3 min read”

  1. ryan says:
    August 23, 2008 at 10:28 am

    I still don’t get how/why I would want to post more/participate more, if all I get is called names! It’s like a childs playground with nana nanaboo boo…and silliness. Seriously, the discourse there, has made me realize how little I ever hope to be apart of this forum again.

  2. Andrew says:
    August 23, 2008 at 10:41 am

    I abandoned forums long ago for just this reason – dominated by a small vocal minority of old timers who hate their dominance/opinions being questioned by newcomers. Any attempt at discussion or a difference of opinion is met as being a troll.

    Did I read the forums correctly? that the magazines editor dismissed bloggers as being lazy journalisum. I wonder if this view is endemic in the print world? It could explain a lot.

  3. Joe Roberts, CSW says:
    August 23, 2008 at 11:17 am

    Thanks, guys.

    The question I’d ask them is, why would anyone want to stay through the hazing period to become a member of a club like that?

  4. Catie says:
    August 23, 2008 at 10:50 pm

    Huzzah! You fought a good and at least a clean fight, unlike…

    In the mean time, I agree that the WS Forum is not the place to have a decent and reasonable adult discussion while there are too many anonymous poo-flinging winged monkeys lurching about.

    I don’t know why I should be surprised about the comment from the WS Forum that their reactions to new posters are equivalent of “initiation.” Talk about an equivalent of playground or good ol’ boys…

    I have also added to my blog regarding today’s experience – under the comment section.

    Cheers,
    C~

  5. Dirty says:
    August 24, 2008 at 4:53 am

    Love WS staff’s comments and those by some of their board rats- Completely reaffirms my impressions of these fine feathered folk.

  6. Willyboy says:
    August 24, 2008 at 11:10 am

    Dude your tenacity is admirable, but I believe Andrew has it right regarding most forums. Anyone so rude, arrogant and cavalier in dismissing you (or CSW, WSET) is unlikely to seriously consider anything you say in defense. Arguing with fools is hard work with little or no reward. I enjoy your blog very much; please focus there. If you insist on carrying on the battle at WS we will have to make you a superhero outfit. Hmmm…’The Vin-dicator’? so please hangup the ‘Vin-dicator’ cape and tights and focus there.

  7. Willyboy says:
    August 24, 2008 at 11:21 am

    I couldn’t resist another haiku on this:

    Trolls center their world
    Crystal clear myopia
    Discordant deafness

  8. Joe Roberts, CSW says:
    August 24, 2008 at 12:21 pm

    Solidarity, my brothers & sisters!

    Thanks for the show of support (and esp. to Catie for jumping into the snake pit with me). I really appreciate it – and don't worry, I didn't waste too much time on the forum, and I think I did manage to win over a person or two.

    It's certainly not worth additional time from any of us in terms of the Goldstein stuff. Hopefully, the other useful aspects of the forum don't take a negative publicity hit from this.

    I'm also sure that I'd look pretty bad in tights, so no superhero activity from me in the future (alternative title: "Elitist Entitlement Ego Man", or "E3"!).

    And I'd be remiss if I forgot to highlight the return of the willyboy haiku! Nicely done (as always)…

  9. Joe Roberts, CSW says:
    August 25, 2008 at 9:00 am

    A glimmer of hope!

    From the WS Forums, under the topic of how new forum posters have been treated, comes this response from a forum member:

    "Individual feuding aside, I have a pretty thick skin, and I have been a wine forum host for years, but even I have lurked more than posted because of the lack of moderation and courtesy here. Pointing out the total board membership is meaningless, because there are only a few dozen names that one sees participating. The fact is, until this board grows up a bit and either has active moderators or becomes self-policing, the board IS losing valuable potentials."

    It's not all gloom & doom over there!

Comments are closed.

Dude’s New Books

Wine Taster's Guide Now Available!

“Bravo! Wine Taster's Guide is a perfect primer for both wine novices and learning enthusiasts." ―Evan Goldstein, Master Sommelier

Wine Taster's Journal Now Available!

"Wine Taster's Journal belongs in everyone's cellar… preferably wine-stained, dog-eared, and well-used.” ―Brian Freedman, wine/spirits/travel columnist

Get Some Wine

Popular Stuff

  • Wine Reviews: Weekly Mini Round-Up For January 18, 2021
    Wine Reviews: Weekly Mini Round-Up For January 18, 2021
  • Wine Reviews: Weekly Mini Round-Up For December 21, 2020
    Wine Reviews: Weekly Mini Round-Up For December 21, 2020
  • Get Ready to Shove Some Wine Down Your Face! (Wine Taster's Guide Official Release!)
    Get Ready to Shove Some Wine Down Your Face! (Wine Taster's Guide Official Release!)
  • Are “Bin End” Wines Really A Good Deal? How To Avoid Getting Tebow-ed At The Bin
    Are “Bin End” Wines Really A Good Deal? How To Avoid Getting Tebow-ed At The Bin
  • Wine Reviews: Weekly Mini Round-Up For January 11, 2021
    Wine Reviews: Weekly Mini Round-Up For January 11, 2021

About + Contact

Joe Roberts

Joe Roberts

Certified Specialist of Wine & WSET Advanced
Author, speaker, consultant, wine judge, & critic.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS Feed

Find Stuff

Sign up, lushes!

Join 36,560 other subscribers

Fine Print

This site is licensed under Creative Commons.

Code of Ethics and Privacy Policies.

Play nice!

Get The Guide

Wine Tasters Guide Footer
#1 New Release in Amazon's Wine Tasting category
This site uses cookies. Duh. Cookie Policy
©2021 1 Wine Dude
Yo yo YO!

Wine Tasters Guide InstagramWell, hello there!

If you like what you’re reading (and want to like more of what you’re drinking), consider subscribing.

If you’re up for a more immersive wine learning experience, check out my books and other services.

Cheers!

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.