1 Wine Dude

A Serious Wine Blog For the Not-So-Serious Drinker

Menu
  • Home
  • About
    • New? Start Here!
    • PR & Samples
    • Press & What-Have-You
  • Wine
    • by badge
      • crowd pleaser
      • elegant
      • kick-ass
      • overachiever
      • sexy
    • Full Reviews
    • Mini-Reviews
  • Stalk
    • facebook
    • LinkedIn
    • Instagram
    • News Break
    • pinterest
    • twitter
    • YouTube
  • Sign Up
  • Books
  • Services
  • Contact
Menu
1 Wine Dude
San Diego pier bubbles 2018

Critics Challenge 2018 Highlights2 min read

Posted on June 8, 2018June 3, 2018 by 1WineDude

in on the road, wine news

San Diego pier bubbles 2018
Staying Classy with bubbles in San Diego

Once again, I had both the pleasure and the honor of judging at the annual Critics Challenge wine competition, held in (stay classy!) San Diego and helmed by WineReviewOnline.com‘s Robert Whitley. This year, I was paired up with talented author Linda Murphy (whose book American Wine you should absolutely check out, because it kicks all kinds of ass).

San Diego view 2018Critics Challenge is top-notch, with excellent, experienced judges and a killer-good volunteer crew (yeah, I don’t understand why they keep inviting me back, either). So the results should, I’d argue, be taken seriously, and you can check out the full list of 2018 medal winners right now at http://www.criticschallenge.com/results.htm.

I wanted to highlight the wines that Linda and I collectively awarded Platinum, as there are some fantastic wines – several of which are surprising bargains – in that lineup of winners. This is why we judge them blind, folks! Fortunately for all of us, picking up many of these wines won’t make the bank account seem appreciably lighter…

Critics Challenge 2018 judging
Getting and judge-y & shit

Alexander Valley Vineyards Temptation Zinfandel 2015, $14

Banfi Brunello Di Montalcino 2013, $75

Banfi Belnero 2014, Toscana $29 (100% Sangiovese)

Bel Colle Simposio Barolo 2013, $60

2018 Critics Challenge dinner
I was the only ham on the menu at dinner…

 

Brancaia TRE 2014, Rosso di Toscana IGT (Sangiovese 80%; with Merlot; Cabernet Sauvignon)

Due Mari Maremma Toscana 2015, $35 (Sangiovese 60%; Merlot 20%; Cabernet Sauvignon 10%; Other Reds 10%)

Falkner Winery Chardonnay 2017, Temecula Valley $30

Kim Crawford Wines Sauvignon Blanc 2017, Marlborough $18

Line 39 Pinot Noir 2016, California $11 (!!!)

McWilliams Evans & Tate “Bright As Day” Chardonnay 2015, Australia $10 (!!!)

Navarro Muscat 2017
A delight

Navarro Vineyards Estate Bottled Dry Muscat Blanc 2017, Anderson Valley $22

Prophecy Vin de France Rosé 2017, $14

Très Chic Pays d’Oc Rosé 2017, $17 (Grenache and Cinsault, baby!)

White Oak Vineyards & Winery “Mighty Oak” Proprietary Red 2014, Sonoma County $19 (28% Cabernet Sauvignon; 16% Cabernet Franc; 56% Merlot, in case you cared)

Windsor Vineyards Private Reserve Sauvignon Blanc 2016, North Coast $16

Wine Spots Wines Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon 2015, $30

Moët & Chandon NV MCIII Brut 001.14 Champagne
Magnum bottle, magnum stopper, magnum price

And, for sh*ts & giggles, an added bonus:

Moët & Chandon NV MCIII Brut 001.14 Champagne, $650/magnum (ok, so that’s not that much of a bargain… but we had it twice at dinners and it’s the kind of heady, floral, yeasty opulence that’s just a total treat, provided that you have the available cash).

Cheers!

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • More
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)

Related

6 thoughts on “Critics Challenge 2018 Highlights2 min read”

  1. Bob Henry says:
    September 4, 2018 at 4:23 am

    Joe,

    I see in one of the photos what appears to be a form for wine notetaking.

    In assessing and rating a wine, what scoring scale were the judges using?

    Were the judge’s ratings an overall assessment of the wine?

    Or were the judges asked to discretely evaluate the “components” of the wine — such as its appearance, color, aroma, bouquet, volatile acidity, overall acidity, sweetness, body, flavor, astringency, and overall quality — assign individual points, then add up the score?

    Regards,

    Bob

    See: http://winegourd.blogspot.com/2018/09/the-poor-mathematics-of-wine-quality.html

    1. 1WineDude says:
      September 4, 2018 at 9:12 am

      Bob – for CC, it’s overall, medals Silver and above only, also points for certain levels of medals and written feedback/comments on reac wine above a certain medal range. Judges work in pairs but consensus need not be reached (highest medal “wins”).

      1. Bob Henry says:
        September 5, 2018 at 12:18 am

        Do judges assign a wine a “class” level — Gold, Silver, Bronze — but not a numerical score?

        1. Bob Henry says:
          September 5, 2018 at 12:20 am

          Aside: Before beginning to critique the first flight of any grape variety, do the judges get a “warm up” wine made from that same grape to “calibrate” their palates?

          1. Bob Henry says:
            September 5, 2018 at 12:22 am

            Anecdote: I recall a comment once made by Tim Mondavi while he was winemaker at Mondavi winery.

            He said it took him about a dozen samples of a single grape variety wine before his palate was warmed up and ready to critique.

            1. 1WineDude says:
              September 5, 2018 at 7:57 am

              Hey Bob,

              Scores are only officially given at certain medal levels, but in CC the judges can reach the medal through any process that they see fit provided that they can justify it if there is discussion or if, say, a Platinum medal gets challenged by the chief judges after they taste it. IIRC, there is a warm-up wine provided at the start of each day of judging.

Comments are closed.

Dude’s New Books

Wine Taster's Guide Now Available!

“Bravo! Wine Taster's Guide is a perfect primer for both wine novices and learning enthusiasts." ―Evan Goldstein, Master Sommelier

Wine Taster's Journal Now Available!

"Wine Taster's Journal belongs in everyone's cellar… preferably wine-stained, dog-eared, and well-used.” ―Brian Freedman, wine/spirits/travel columnist

Get Some Wine


Vivino 15% Off Code: 2021NEW15 (1st Time Buyer)

Popular Stuff

  • Wine Reviews: Weekly Mini Round-Up for February 22, 2021
    Wine Reviews: Weekly Mini Round-Up for February 22, 2021
  • Wine Product Review Round-up: Special Edition
    Wine Product Review Round-up: Special Edition
  • Bitterness in White Wines (No... Really!)
    Bitterness in White Wines (No... Really!)
  • Wine In the Time of Coronavirus, Part 34: Make Wine Like a Girl (Women Run the Show at Benzinger & Imagery)
    Wine In the Time of Coronavirus, Part 34: Make Wine Like a Girl (Women Run the Show at Benzinger & Imagery)
  • The First – And Last – 160 Days: What Does Gary Vaynerchuk’s Exit Mean For The Wine World?
    The First – And Last – 160 Days: What Does Gary Vaynerchuk’s Exit Mean For The Wine World?

About + Contact

Joe Roberts

Joe Roberts

Certified Specialist of Wine & WSET Advanced
Author, speaker, consultant, wine judge, & critic.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS Feed

Find Stuff

Sign up, lushes!

Join 36,559 other subscribers

Fine Print

This site is licensed under Creative Commons.

Code of Ethics and Privacy Policies.

Play nice!

Get The Guide

Wine Tasters Guide Footer
#1 New Release in Amazon's Wine Tasting category
This site uses cookies. Duh. Cookie Policy
©2021 1 Wine Dude
Yo yo YO!

Wine Tasters Guide InstagramWell, hello there!

If you like what you’re reading (and want to like more of what you’re drinking), consider subscribing.

If you’re up for a more immersive wine learning experience, check out my books and other services.

Cheers!

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.